|

ou
can't have everything. Where would you put it all?"-Stephen Wright.
Actually, truth be told, the new Yamaha EX5 pretty much does
offer everything-at least everything you could reasonably ask of a
pre-millennium synthesizer workstation. Under the unassuming hood
of this single instrument is the most complete collection of synth
technologies you'll find anywhere, anyplace. We're talking old technologies
(subtractive analog-style synthesis, FM synthesis, an arpeggiator,
and an onboard sequencer with many of the same editing commands found
in dedicated boxes produced by Yamaha and its competitors more than
a decade ago), current technologies (sampling and sample playback,
physical modeling, multi-effects), and new technologies (something
called "Formulated Digital Signal Processing"-a complex series of
algorithms that enable finely controlled pitch- or velocity-specific
processing). Add to this a strong MIDI implementation, numerous expansion
options (including, unusually, a professional digital output), and
a 76-note keyboard. The result is a synthesizer that not only excels
in producing some of the finest retro sounds out there (with particularly
strong emulations of Seventies-style keyboards such as Rhodes, Wurlitzer,
Clavinet, and Hammond and Farfisa/Vox organs) but also provides a
broad palette of new tone colors never before heard and a massive
set of tools with which to create your own sonic masterpieces.
In short, this is one serious instrument.
But,
as Mr. Wright so aptly pointed out, there's a tradeoff for having
all these goodies in box. The issue certainly isn't flexibility,
and it isn't really price, either: The EX5's price tag of $2,695
is actually less than you'd pay for many competing 76-note keyboards.
(There's also a 61-note keyboard version-the EX7-and the EX5R rackmount,
both priced at $2,195.) Instead, the major restriction is computing
power. One could reasonably argue that the EX5 is a bit under-endowed
in this department, especially when you really put it through its
paces. That said, this is still an amazing product-one that not
only encapsulates the best of the past 25 years' worth of development
but also gives a good sense of what the next generation of synthesizers
is going to be about.
Physically,
the EX5 is a beast; figure on having lots of available real estate
and a heavy- duty stand to place it on. In addition to the usual
complement of footpedal, footswitch, and breath controller inputs
and center-sprung pitch-bend wheel, you'll find two modulation wheels
(one center detented) and a ribbon controller (a personal favorite
of mine), as well as a series of six "soft" knobs under the large
central backlit LCD. All of these can be used to alter just about
any aspect of the sound in real time (including effects parameters),
and can also be assigned to independently transmit any MIDI control
change message. This, along with the EX5's dual MIDI inputs and
outputs, makes it well-suited as a master controller, either in
the home studio or onstage.
Out
of the box, the EX5 provides two analog inputs (for sampling) and
four analog outputs; all are unbalanced 1/4" jacks. For another $150,
you can install an optional board that adds an additional four analog
outputs-or, for two hundred bucks, you can spring for a board that
adds a stereo AES/EBU digital output on XLR jacks, as well as a word
clock input to ensure proper synchronization. Unfortunately, there's
only room for one or the other of these output options. Other expansion
options include a SCSI interface ($250) and Flash ROM memory expansion
(call Vital Technology at [877] 926-2425 for 16 meg modules, priced
at around $200 to $300)-more about these shortly.
If you've worked
with any of Yamaha's keyboards over the past ten years, much of the
EX5's nomenclature (and, alas, the morass of nested menus) will be
familiar. Individual sounds are called "voices," while collections
of sounds layered, velocity-switched, or assigned to different keyboard
ranges (and/or set to respond to different MIDI channels) are called
"performances." The instrument comes loaded with 256 preset voices
(including six drum kits) and 64 preset performances, and there are
another 256 slots in which to store your own voices, plus 64 more
slots for the storage of your own performances. Most of the presets
are sonically excellent, and many of them, particularly the keyboard
and string sounds, are absolutely superb.
Four basic synthesis techniques
are available: sample playback (of both permanently stored ROM waves
and your own custom samples), virtual acoustic modeling of pipe and
string sounds (as found in Yamaha's VL series of synths), virtual
physical modeling of analog synthesizers (the oscillator-into-filter-into-amplifier
model found in the old analog synths of yore, as well as Yamaha's
more recent AN series; here, this process is used to create FM sounds),
and the previously noted "Formulated Digital Signal Processing" (FDSP
for short). The latter provides models of devices like electric piano
and electric guitar pickups (with user-defined properties, such as
positioning and placement) and allows you to create the weirdest flanging,
phasing, and ring and pulse width modulation effects you've ever heard,
all of which can change dramatically as you play different notes at
different key velocities.
Each of these synthesis techniques has its
strengths and weaknesses. For example, sample playback provides the
most realistic sounds, since they are digital recordings of the actual
sounds themselves-but real-time control is limited. In contrast, virtual
acoustic modeling sounds provide phenomenal expressivity but don't
necessarily yield the most convincing sonic emulations. In recognition
of this, the EX5 allows you to combine different synthesis processes
within a single voice, though certain restrictions apply-for example,
you can only combine a VL "element" with sample playback elements.
As you might expect, there's a huge number of editable parameters,
making the EX5 a dream come true for propellerheads like me who enjoy
customizing sounds or creating new ones from scratch. Although many
menus let you adjust multiple parameters simultaneously via the six
"soft" knobs, the fact is that there are lots of menus and way too
little screen space for all the parameters that need to be viewed.
This is one synth that will benefit greatly from a computer-based
patch editor; while there will undoubtedly be a number of these on
the market soon, it is unfortunate that Yamaha didn't develop one
themselves for inclusion with the instrument.
There is, however, a
Mac- and Windows-based sample editor provided on disk, but bear in
mind that, while the EX5 can sample, it wasn't designed to be a sampler.
This means that you can record your own CD-quality (44.1 kHz, 16-bit)
sounds into it, but the onboard editing is sparse, and the storage
capabilities are extremely limited. Out of the box, there's only 1
meg of RAM provided: This translates to a puny twelve seconds or so
of mono sampling time, or six seconds of stereo. You can install up
to 64 megabytes of additional RAM, using standard 72-pin DRAM SIMMs,
but RAM memory is volatile, meaning that all your samples are erased
when the EX5 is powered down. A better option is the aforementioned
Flash ROM memory; it's currently available in only 16 megabyte modules
(larger ones are being tested), but at least the data is held in memory
even when the power is off.
Getting samples into
and out of the EX5 is somewhat problematic, though. There is a built-in
floppy disk drive that reads standard PC-formatted disks and is
capable of importing WAV or AIFF files (as well as Akai S1000 files),
but these must of necessity be small (less than 1.4 meg) and therefore
short in length. To import or export longer sample files, you'll
need to add the SCSI option, which allows you to connect pretty
much any hard drive or CD-ROM player. This would be a good thing
except for the fact that the EX5's SCSI implementation is way slower
than the rest of the world's. As a result, loading and saving times
are very poky, even if you hook up a super-whizzbang, extra-fast
hard drive. You can completely forget about using SCSI to load samples
into RAM during live performance; your audience will be filing out
the door long before the transfer is complete. Instead, you'll need
to opt for loading sample data into Flash ROM in the comfort of
your home beforehand-an alternative that's both somewhat costly
(adding $450 to $550 to the instrument's basic price) and limiting
(16 megs vs. 65 megs).
The "workstation" label
implies the presence of an onboard MIDI sequencer; the EX5 actually
has three of them. One is a fairly standard linear 16-track "song"
sequencer, which has 30,000-note capacity and 480 ppq resolution but
unfortunately only holds one song in memory at a time. The second
is an eight-track "pattern" sequencer, which allows you to record
short, repetitive phrases, drum machine style. The third is the arpeggiator.
All three offer pretty much all of the editing features you'd expect
in a dedicated hardware sequencer, including event list editing and
various quantization routines, such as a real-time "groove" playback
quantization that lets you impose a predefined "feel" (one of the
100 presets or your own prerecorded groove) onto your recording. Integration
between the three is especially tight-for example, you can not only
assemble patterns into a song (and then overdub linearly on top),
you can extract sections of specific tracks within a song and turn
them into patterns or arpeggiation "styles"; you can even record the
output of the arpeggiator into a song track. Arpeggiators are, of
course, an important adjunct to techno music, and you're unlikely
to find any more comprehensive or powerful than the one here. There
are fifty preset arpeggiation "styles," many of which are highly syncopated;
you can also create your own from scratch. Arpeggiation operation
can also be written as part of a voice or performance, so it is easy
to create a sound that is in fact a whole series of notes-a characteristic
of some of the EX5's more esoteric presets.
And what would a modern synthesizer be without effects? As you
might expect, the EX5 excels here as well. First of all, every element
within a voice and every voice within a performance can feed independent
reverb and chorus effects. (There are twelve reverb types and seventeen
chorus types to pick from.) Happily, the reverb tails are smooth
and exhibit little of the graininess often found in keyboard effects.
In addition, there are two insertion effects, which can be applied
to individual elements within a voice or (within certain restrictions)
individual voices within a performance. These include many of the
chorus effects types, plus EQ, compression, amp simulation, autopanning,
and pitch change, as well as a number of clearly Nineties algorithms,
such as low
resolution, noisy,
and digital
turntable (complete with programmable click density and level).
There are loads of other features too. Space precludes listing
all of them, but some of my favorites include resampling (where
your playing of an internal voice or performance, including its
multieffects, can be saved as a new sample), key mapping (where
each note on the keyboard can be used to trigger a pattern or play
back a sample), scene memories (which allow you to create and store
two variations on a voice and then morph between them in real time
with a wheel or footpedal), the ability to apply different tunings
(including microtunings) independently to each element within a
voice, a dedicated front panel effects
bypass button, sample-and-hold LFO waveforms and the ability
to modulate LFO speed (particularly useful in creating realistic
vibrato), "controller sets" (collections of controller routings,
allowing both multiple sources to a single destination and single
sources to multiple destinations; up to sixteen can be programmed
per voice), the ability to receive MIDI Time Code and to transmit
MIDI Machine Control, and the ability to save sequence data as Standard
MIDI Files (SMFs) and to play SMFs directly from disk (you can even
accompany them in real time) without having to load them into the
onboard sequencer.
As wonderful as all
this sounds, there is a caveat, as we warned you at the beginning
of this review. While the CPU at the heart of the EX5 handles basic
operations flawlessly, it seems to fall short when you start placing
demands on the instrument. For example, there is the SCSI issue
noted above. There is also a noticeable delay when storing voices,
and a momentary muting of all tracks when a single track is muted
in the sequencer. And limitations and restrictions abound: While
total polyphony is 126 notes, VL elements are monophonic and AN
elements can play a maximum of only two notes. Only two voices can
be layered together in performance mode (though a single voice can
itself contain up to four layers), and a performance can only contain
one voice that uses VL or AN synthesis. In these kinds of performances,
only one insert effect can be applied, and only to one voice. (Even
in performances that contain all sample-playback voices, the insertion
effects can be applied only to a maximum of four voices.) Worst
of all, there can be audible note smearing when playing dense chords
of two voices layered in performance mode (either from the keyboard
or via MIDI), and sequencer playback timing can suffer-sometimes
tremendously-when asked to play back dense tracks or while overdubbing
clusters of chords.
But, hey, this is the bleeding edge. Warts and all, the EX5 pretty
much redefines the term "full-featured." It's a superb choice for
recording or for use as a master controller in a MIDI home studio.
If you're into programming your own sounds (and you don't mind battling
a truly awful owner's manual), this is total hog heaven. For live
use, I'd be a little more cautious, especially if you frequently
need multitimbral operation or rely on using a sequencer to play
"one-man band" accompaniments, but there's no denying the impact
this puppy should have on keyboard players everywhere for some time
to come. So you can have everything-now you've just gotta figure
out where to put it all!
Special thanks to
Athan Billias, Phil Clendeninn, and Avery Burdette.
Reprinted with permission from Musician, courtesy of BPI Communications,
Inc., New York, NY © March 1999. All rights reserved.
|